There was a fairly heated discussion here a few weeks ago, as to whether or not punching a vent hole allowed dirty oil and contaminants to drain back into the engine. I’m not sure a consensus was ever reached?
Curious if you need to punch a hold in the top to get it to drain.
Larry
Here is link to their filter drain tool. Bummed they require a $100 minimum order.
https://www.ustool.com/tp433-oil-change-accessories-p-3991.html
Reading the instructions, it feels like drilling holes in the filter would contaminate the filter element with metallic chips.
For folks who have done this - do the drill chips confound your visual inspection of the filter element after removing the filter and cutting it open?
What is @this thing”?This thing lets you surgically replace your oil filter. View attachment 112554
You guys are WAY over thinking this.... Here's a totally ghetto, but 100% effective way to remove your spin off filter without a drop of oil touching the airplane. VAF member and guru @Taltruda turned me onto this method. He should have patented it. LOL
View attachment 112794
View attachment 112795
View attachment 112796

It REALLY is ingenious! Best thing is, when you're done, just wipe it down and its ready for the next time. And the length allows you to drain the oil away from the engine and you don't have to fuss with getting the shape right each time. Just put a pan up on a stool, insert half-pipe under the edge of the filter/engine lip, unscrew the filter and let it run.I had good luck at my last oil change using a form-a-funnel as well. I had to take a picture so I’d remember how to do it next time. I do like the PVC idea though.
+1. Super useful gadgets.One more for form-a-funnel. I've been using one for the last 3 years and really like it. I think I got the idea here on some former post.
I haven't experienced very much success with this method ........ always seems to make a mess, sometimes larger than other times. But it's what I use until I can find another method. I'll probably try the form-a-funnel method next time.I have always placed a plastic bag under/around the filter, then remove it and all the oil goes in the bag. Simple and cheap.
Time to start pulling the nose wheel up on a block of wood when I do oil changes!Soooo...if its a taildragger, and all the wheels are on the ground, the back of the oil filter ) on a horizontal filter mount) is going to be measurably lower than the engine end. Punching a hole at the low end and draining from there should keep the oil from flowing uphill, I’d think.
Nose draggers - ya’ll can argue this out among yourselves!(My nose dragger doesn’t have a Lycoming...)
The form-a-funnel is the one technique that’s allowed me to achieve zero mess. Gravity is the key. The oil “wants” to drain from a single spot where the filter unscrews, and every other technique I’ve used ends up multiplying those spots.I haven't experienced very much success with this method ........ always seems to make a mess, sometimes larger than other times. But it's what I use until I can find another method. I'll probably try the form-a-funnel method next time.
Yeah, I tried the bag once. I'd have been better off just letting it drain straight out the hole onto the engine and floor.I haven't experienced very much success with this method ........ always seems to make a mess, sometimes larger than other times. But it's what I use until I can find another method. I'll probably try the form-a-funnel method next time.