What's new
Van's Air Force

Don't miss anything! Register now for full access to the definitive RV support community.

Funny SODA Flight

tinman451

Member
Here is a short summary of the experience I had trying to secure a medical waiver for an eye condition in case any of you are up against such an issue. This took place several years ago, so things could be a bit different now. I have been giving consideration to getting back into aviation now that my kid is out of college and I have some avbucks available since college and Pharmacy school aren’t bleeding me dry.

It has been several years since I have served as PIC due to an unfortunate medical condition which left me with vertical double vision. To make the situation more entertaining, the image is constantly yo-yoing up and down. What is amazing about the condition is that the only time it was ever a factor with flying was when I was at the top of a loop and was attempting to look “up” to acquire the horizon…what I saw were two horizons, one of which that was stacked on top of another and tilted about 20 degrees. I adapted to this image by using my flight instruments at this stage of the loop in order to make certain I was referencing the “correct” horizon. Once I had mastered this technique, I never had an issue with the condition interfering with safe flight. The brain is amazing…I never had difficulty with landing on the “correct” runway.

I had an endless series of registered mail exchanges with the FAA while working through the medical waiver process. The FAA was not very good to work with, and my medical ended up lapsing due to the requests for more reports from more specialists. I finally reached out to my Senator and had them light a fire under the FAA. About a week later, I was phoned by the FAA and told to expect a letter offering the chance to perform a SODA flight. This set into motion another series of funny circumstances…

My local FSDO did not have an examiner on staff with a tailwheel endorsement, and on top of that, they were unwilling to fly with me in my RV-8 since it was Experimental. I suggested a C-152 rental as an option, but they came back stating the examiner preferred a C-172 so we would not be overly cramped. I had never flown a 172, so I went to a local flight school and rented one for an hour in order to learn how it flew…after flying the RV-8, I was not impressed… After getting a few landings under my belt, I figured I would not embarrass myself too much with the examiner.

The big day arrived and I met the examiner. We discussed my medical condition. He laughed when I told him “I saw twice as much as he did.” which was a great way to start our SODA flight…laughter. I had already pre-flighted the 172. As we walked up to the plane, he climbed up and loosened the fuel cap and confirmed we had fuel. After he climbed down, I climbed up and confirmed that he had put the caps on correctly. When I got down, he asked me what I had done, and I told him I was confirming that he had put the caps back correctly. He then told me he was confirming that the caps were on correctly and that he would now have to check them again since I had touched them….ummm….ok…this is going to be a long pre-flight if we have to keep checking each other’s work over and over. At this point, I was beginning to think I was going to have a bad ride…

I explained to him that I only had one hour in the 172, so it was going to take me a bit longer to work through the engine start checks and so forth…he was ok with the delay since it was in his best interest that I get everything right. Once we got in the air, he was much more relaxed and we had a great flight. I pointed out traffic to him and gave him a good idea of what I was actually seeing. After about 30 minutes, he told me to take him back to the airport and that if I didn’t kill him when landing, we were good to go. He told me it was clear that I was well-adapted to the condition. After shutting down, I asked him what the next steps were going to be, but he only said I would be hearing from FAA HQ in time…uggh!

A couple of weeks later, I received my special issuance medical which made me very happy! Due to the slow-motion registered mail method of exchanging information, the process took months. It seemed archaic that the FAA did not allow email, but I guess they were trying to send some business to their Federal buddies at the USPS… I ended up so frustrated with the process that I stopped flying. The SODA process had cost me several thousand dollars. The good news is that I was never denied a medical, so I can resume flying with the Basic Medical program when I decide to get back into the game down the road…
 
Last edited:
Go fly

Interesting story, thanks for sharing.
But... you jumped through all the hoops and achieved success, only to make it into a loss by giving up flying at least for now? I hope you overcome that and take your 'win' by getting up in the air!
 
Interesting story, thanks for sharing.
But... you jumped through all the hoops and achieved success, only to make it into a loss by giving up flying at least for now? I hope you overcome that and take your 'win' by getting up in the air!

The rest of the story: One year from my special issuance, it was time to renew the waiver. I was contacted by the FAA with requests for things we had already covered the first time around...here we go again! Dr. Silberman, the gent at FAA HQ who granted my special issuance, had departed the FAA leaving me with the need to start over with another Dr there. My patron Senator had departed the Senate leaving me with no outside advocate. They simply wore me down to the point where it was not worth the mental anguish to jump through each hoop as they were presented.

When I am ready to return to flight, it will be under Basic Med...no more endless hoops. They are not happy until we are not happy...
 
Don, I think you will first have to get a special issuance class III again before you can go basic med.

I thought that since my special issuance was granted after July 2006, I would be OK for Basic Med... hoping this is the case. If not, one more round of jumping through hoops...
 
I thought that since my special issuance was granted after July 2006, I would be OK for Basic Med...
Correct. From https://www.aopa.org/advocacy/pilots/medical/basicmed/basicmedspecialissuance:
If you have had or were diagnosed with any of the conditions described below and have not previously had an FAA special issuance authorization for that condition, you may not fly under BasicMed until you have been granted a one-time authorization for special issuance of your medical certificate by the FAA.
 
Last edited:
FAA: We aren't happy until you aren't happy....

The rest of the story: One year from my special issuance, it was time to renew the waiver. I was contacted by the FAA with requests for things we had already covered the first time around...here we go again! Dr. Silberman, the gent at FAA HQ who granted my special issuance, had departed the FAA leaving me with the need to start over with another Dr there. My patron Senator had departed the Senate leaving me with no outside advocate. They simply wore me down to the point where it was not worth the mental anguish to jump through each hoop as they were presented.

When I am ready to return to flight, it will be under Basic Med...no more endless hoops. They are not happy until we are not happy...

Boy, have I seen THIS movie! And there are some ironies in this story...

I had a little run-in with The "C" Word and endured 8.5 weeks of radiation therapy, 5 days a week, then three rounds each of two different chemotherapeutic agents that saved my life! Thanks, Science! One of the main things that saved my sanity.....and there are PLENTY of opportunities to lose THAT!.....was being able to jump in the Cub and go land in a stubble field somewhere in the middle of nowhere or jump in SuzieQ and be in Montana in 2.5 hours visiting friends. Flew up once for lunch and came back! :p:p So I was flying the entire time I was in treatment and afterwords with absolutely no problems. Cancer and treatment did not affect my ability to fly....except for the time commitment during treatment. Radiation: no side effects from that. Chemo: would kick my butt on day 3 after for 24 hours, then I was good. I got pretty good at self-assessment. I would not fly if I did not feel up to performing my best. And I didn't go to Home Depot on day 3! :D

So: I had not been a pilot, I would not be here now as I had NO SYMPTOMS. And it was my AME that found my tumor during my flight physical! He was, however, also the one who told me he would have to submit my now treated diagnosis to the FAA three years after the fact! You are a danger to yourself and others if you have had cancer...... ANY cancer! So we started the process: it took 6 months of paperwork going back and forth and back and forth; they needed more information and yada yada yada etc etc etc. FINALLY I got a special issuance, ironically from Dr. Silberman, that was effective......from the time I first submitted my application 6 months previous!! Which means I could fly for 6 months and have to start all over again!!!:mad::mad::mad: I had been through so much during treatment and now was being told there was another mountain to climb if I wanted to continue flying. It suddenly did not seem to be worth going through all that again. And again in a year. And again in a year. And....... It felt like they were taking the fact that I had had cancer and rubbing it in my face! Great. And I thought the trauma of having had cancer was bad. That seemed minor compared to having it thrown back at me and not being able to fly.....

So: I totally understand your quitting after what you went through as that is exactly what I did. It took me 5 years to start flying again, then under Light Sport rules as the Cub qualified. Then the arduous climb back to Basic Med. The other irony is that Dr. Silberman is now the main consultant for AOPA!:D:D Yeah......we are only here to help you......

Find an AME that is willing to work with you and knows what the FAA needs. It will be good for you and your mental state to get back into flying. Did I mention I understand? You can't let them win.....:cool:
 
Special issuance

There are allegedly several Medical Examiners who can fast track most of these issues. Not certain but I believe Dr. Brent Blue is one. There is also a lady in Oklahoma City area who advertises this service.
 
Don, as I understand the basic med application process you must first hold a “current “ medical certificate and in your case that will require a current special issuance class III. Once you’ve obtained a current medical certificate you will want to go to basic med before the SI expires.

That’s what I had to do several years ago. It is a royal PITA but at least once you’ve gone basic med it’ll be worth the effort and you should be able to maintain it until your condition changes.
 
Don, as I understand the basic med application process you must first hold a “current “ medical certificate and in your case that will require a current special issuance class III. Once you’ve obtained a current medical certificate you will want to go to basic med before the SI expires.
Ah yes, my previous post wasn't really accurate on that account. Oops.
However I would suggest that since you already got an SI and nothing's changed (?) there should be no reason for you to have to go through those same hoops again. Not that they can't make you but AOPA might be able to help with that one.
 
BTW I got an important tidbit from an AME once - when FAA looks at your form 8500-7 or whatever is required for your SI, if they see wording such as "no change", "stable" or words to that effect it can mean the difference between the medical first tier at FAA stamping OK, or bumping it up to some other level that may or may not cause more hoops. Just a thought when you're discussing this with your specialist.
 
OK...the final irony in this goat rope was that my AME was charged with trading prescriptions for controlled substances for sex... 3 years in prison for him.
Now I will need to find a new AME.
 
The good ol FAA

Back in 1994 I was diagnosed with sleep apnea. Mild case according to the pulmonoligist. I had received annual flight physicals from a fellow pilot/ham for several years flying under Class II medical protocol.
The only question Dr.Tom (now gone west) asked was if I felt drowsy or sleepy when I fly or drive. I answered no and he continued to issue my certs until my MI in 98 when I grounded myself and went through FAA hoops to re qualify for Class II. I have been flying under basic med for about however long it's been in existence with no issues. If they ever find out I'm a registered Republican, I'm screwed...:D
 
Current medical

You don’t need a current medical. You need to have had a current medical in 2006 or later, not been denied on most recent, and not having the listed conditions.
 
Don, as I understand the basic med application process you must first hold a “current “ medical certificate and in your case that will require a current special issuance class III. Once you’ve obtained a current medical certificate you will want to go to basic med before the SI expires.

That’s what I had to do several years ago. It is a royal PITA but at least once you’ve gone basic med it’ll be worth the effort and you should be able to maintain it until your condition changes.

Hmmmm...don't think so:

https://www.faa.gov/licenses_certificates/airmen_certification/basic_med

And on the FAQ

Q9: Do I have to always “hold or have held a medical certificate” in the past 10 years?
A: No. There is no 10-year requirement, or a 10-year “look-back”. You only need to have held a medical certificate at any point after July 14, 2006. If you meet that provision, then you never have to hold a medical certificate again to operate under BasicMed, unless you develop one of the conditions identified in 14 CFR 68.9 that require you to get a special issuance (i.e., psychosis, epilepsy, heart replacement, etc.).
 
Back
Top