Hi Brian, the blo proof gasket will offer the best sealing for an uneven flange, but yours looks to be too warped to seal properly. The best solution is to file the face back flat, but I'm curious to know why it is warping like that because that is just something we don't see with a 1/4" flange. At any rate we are glad to re face the flange. Clint/ Vetterman Exhaust