Captain Avgas
Well Known Member
Looks like around 25% of accidents have a mechanical cause. It is probably underestimated. I can't do much about the pilot culture, but I can help people build better airplanes.
I don't give a hoot what area you improve...
Dan, you are on the ball as usual. In fact the single largest category of accident in the Experimental category is mechanical failure.
No guys, it's not CFIT, or landing accidents, or low level manouevering, or aerobatics....it's mechanical failure!!!
And mechanical failure is the category of accident most likely to cause injury to third parties and their property (ie. the general public on the ground)....which is what we REALLY need to be worried about if we want to maintain privileges.
But while people are happy to talk ad infinitum about Experimental pilot aptitude and attitude they are not so happy to discuss obvious shortcomings in the build process. And the real truth is that many firewall forward installations in the Experimental category are not amateur built... but amateurishly built. And that applies to RVs as well.
Good instructions and available parts make construction of the airframe in most modern kits largely a matter of assembly....but that's not the case firewall forward. The large range of engine/componentry options means that kit manufacturers cannot provide detailed drawings and components for every FWF combination....thus leaving mechanical neophytes to make largely intuitive decisions. Sure there's ways to obtain the proper knowledge but many builders are so intent on getting their plane finished that they don't avail themselves of that knowledge. And the same goes for maintenance.
And then there's the auto conversions. As a rule of thumb the enthusiasm with which builders embrace the concept of the auto conversion is generally inversely proportional to their understanding of things mechanical. As a consequence the failure rate with home grown auto conversions is just horrific. It's time to call a spade a spade.
If everyone here wants to reduce the accident statistics they should start with the biggest statistic and acknowledge that a lot of Experimental aircraft are flying with very dodgy FWF systems and substandard FWF maintenance. It will not bode well for us if we keep sweeping this matter under the rug.
Last edited: