Use the gauge
I thought so also. I squeezed the first -12 in there and it cleated over BIG TIME. The -11's produced a much better shop head. Quite difficult to prevent cleating on these, especially if your holes are not dead-on centered.
OR, you could just weld the ends on there.
When in doubt, use the rivet length gauge, or measure the material and break out you calculator a la Chapter 5 in your builders manual.