Canadian Experience
We've used almost all the common carriers for 15 years shipping all over the world. We rarely insure anything now with Fedex as they almost never lose or destroy shipments.
Nightmares with DHL including fraud, not giving us insurance money etc.
UPS- nightmares again when they lose something. Can you say small claims court! Brokerage costs on ground US goods coming to Canada are a killer. Ship by 2 or 3 day air. It is cheaper, faster and safer.
Purolator (Canada) dropped my cylinder heads off a truck onto the concrete and smashed one- $1000 down the drain and got $2/lb. I'll never ship with them again after this one 3 weeks ago.
USPS works pretty well.
But when it absolutely, positively has to get there- Fedex is truly #1. In over 5000 shipments, they have lost only one item and damaged only one more. I got money back for both (after saying you pay me or I take my $40K account next door). Really, they are the best in my experience but all of them make mistakes.
The Warsaw convention limiting carrier liability is a crock and should be abolished. When a carrier takes my goods and they are reasonably packaged, I expect them to be delivered and cared for, not kicked up the stairs like in the Jim Carrey movie. If they bust it, they should own it. It's called taking responsibility.
Why carriers screw customers when they damage or lose stuff is beyond me. Make it right and even the ticked off customers will probably stay with you. Burn them and you'll lose a lot more money than the claim.
I started a special web page on one of these carriers and had people E-mailing me from all over the world telling me their horror stories which I posted there. After about a year and a half, I was contacted and asked if I'd remove the site. I replied I would when they wrote a letter of apology to me and refunded the $2665 they owed me. I got the check the next week. The power of the web my friends.
Now, when my 6A kit came from van's by truck, it had two nice holes in the fuselage box from a forklift. While the driver was here, I popped the lid. As Maxwell Smart would say- "missed by that much" About 2 more inches and the trucking company would have owned a QB fuselage. They just stopped short of the firewall.
The costs are getting up there due to fuel surcharges for sure and we are sending more by post than ever as customers balk at the prices of the other carriers. Don't use the UPS stores shipping to Canada, you pay a big premium.