I just got mine back from Bill and they came out great. He will send you some layout samples and then work with you to customize yours. His name and email are below. He is very fast also.
Sorry, I don't have a specific source, but Van's keeps a set of business cards on their main counter from a guy who does them. I've heard good things about his service (but not so good that I remember his name ). Just give Van's a call. Sounds like a trophy shop would be just as good, and probably faster and cheaper.