We've sorta/kinda has the same issues along the way...
UMA single pointers will sometimes pass, sometimes not.
Winter altimeters are for the most part pretty darned too but cost nearly $1K.
The certified Mid-Continents are really good, but really expensive.
The MGL units we've used and they are also good, but when people are going with backups that are "steam gauges", they usually want an aneroid non-digital instrument to backup their digital EFIS, which is why they aren't as popular (let's please not get into that discussion here). I remain rather ambivalent about that particular issue. We have installed the MGL's and they do work pretty darned well. They can be a little difficult to read in the sun, but as Ranier says they will run on a 9V batt (just remember to replace it once and awhile).
The falcon units sort of fall into the same category as the UMA stuff. Supposedly both UMA and Falcon have been working on 2/3 pointer small altimeters for years, but I've yet to see anything from them just yet. UMA and Falcon single pointers have been the de-facto backups for the large majority of people to date, although as I said we have done some MGL's and some Mid-continents as well.
Not a lot of options I know, but that's where we're at!
Cheers,
Stein