The Winter 2-1/4 inch alitimter with a typical three-hand movement appears to be a good choice for a small back-up altimiter. However, if you are intending to maintain IFR certification of your pitot-static system, I believe the back-up will have to meet the same requirements for accuracy as the primairy.
Unfortunately, the Winter 4 FGH40 performance specifications show an unacceptable indication error of plus or minus 120 feet at 8000 feet, and twice that much at 15,000 feet. (I found the specificaitons on the Cumulus Soaring website at
www.cumulus-soaring.com ).
It looks like the MGL ALT-1 or ALT-2 may still be the best choice.