Hi, that super thin pure aluminum coating on the alloy is very soft and delicate. You can mar it by just rubbing your finger hard on it. (trust me, I know

p )No matter what I do, I get a slight amount of scuffing reguardless of my mirror finish flush set. But it is a very minor thing to me. One must hold a light on the scuffing to see it clearly and it's only around the rivet head. I don't use the rubber collar. I figure that any scuffing of that thin 'alclad' isn't going to show through the paint job. To me, the 'alclad' coating is only for corrosion control during construction. If it scratches, I rub out the scratches with the scotchbrite and destroy the 'alclad' in the process, oh well, it gets primed very soon anyway. I hope my experience helps.
Fritz