VAF Forums

VAF Forums (https://vansairforce.net/community/index.php)
-   RV General Discussion/News (https://vansairforce.net/community/forumdisplay.php?f=2)
-   -   Oil Cooler Air Door (https://vansairforce.net/community/showthread.php?t=66901)

Neal@F14 01-04-2011 10:44 PM

Oil Cooler Air Door
 
To help get the oil temps up for cold weather flying, I've conjured up an oil cooler air door, electrically operated with a Ray Allen trim servo. First test flight shows it works quite well. With the door completely closed, we got it up to 195-200 on a pretty cold day, then slowly opened the door a little with the push of a button and oil temps came down to a nice 185 and stayed there, where we couldn't get 135 without the airflow restriction. The door is covered with thick felt glued on the cooler side for cushion/anti-chafe purposes. We'll keep a close eye on it to be sure there is no wear of the oil cooler face, but the felt is pretty soft and should not pose a problem. I connected the potentiometer wires of the servo to a Dynon D120 general purpose input and use the aileron trim indication on the screen to show when the door is open (left) and closed (right) as a display and it seems to work pretty slick.

Will the servo last under the cowl? Who knows...
Will it open up wide enough in the summertime? We'll find out... It can always come off quite easily with a quick pull of a piano hinge pin and the servo linkage.

It was a neat project and that's what's so cool about an experimental, you get to experiment! And if it doesn't work out, and has to be removed, it was a learning experience.

Door closed:


Door opened:


More construction pics here: http://img691.imageshack.us/g/img4686k.jpg/

PCHunt 01-04-2011 11:42 PM

An obvious question would be: What will the oil temp do if the door gets stuck in the closed position?

Neal@F14 01-05-2011 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PCHunt (Post 500661)
An obvious question would be: What will the oil temp do if the door gets stuck in the closed position?

Pretty much the same results you'd expect to get from any kind of other oil cooler door/shutter mechanism that gets stuck closed.

As long as the OAT is around 40 deg F or lower, I would guestimate the oil temps to max out at about 210-215 based on what we've seen in the air thus far with the door in place, and also with aluminum foil tape covering various amounts of the back of the cooler on previous flights. The amount of air leakage past the cutouts in the door to clear the motor mount tubes will still allow about the amount of air equivalent to always having one row uncovered.

Obviously, if the servo fails in the shut position with warmer OATs, then the door will have to come off until the servo is repaired. The door comes off easily with the snip of one safety wire loop and pulling the hinge pin, and removal of one small cotter pin and clevis pin.

Fred.Stucklen 01-05-2011 09:11 AM

Oil Coller Door
 
Here's another great way to implement a cockpit controllable oil cooler door. This one is for a firewall mounted cooler. The parts on the #3 cyclider baffle are from a wood working shop vac system available just about anywhere wood working products are sold.

Bob Kuykendall 01-05-2011 11:28 AM

***Grain-o-salt warning: I'm not an engineer***

I'd be a little bit concerned with this arrangement because it applies a non-trivial bending moment to the plunger that comes out of the servo.

The figure below shows the arrangement as I understand it at the top. Below that, we see that the force of the air pressure behind the door applies a force F to the plunger. Resolving F into x and y components, we see that the y component trying to bend the plunger is almost as large as the x component that the plunger resists by moving in and out of the servo. At the bottom is a possible revision that almost completely eliminates the bending moment applied to the servo plunger.



An interesting question is, how great is the force applied to the door? According to this article, we might reasonably expect around 2" H2O, or 0.072 lbs/in^2 of pressure drop across the oil cooler. Further guessing that the oil cooler area is 4"x6" or 24 square inches, that gives a total force of 24*0.072=~1.7 lbs. So if you can pull about 2 lbs on the center of the door and not have the servo plunger bend or bind, you're probably OK.

If anybody sees any substantial errors in my understanding, please post up!

Thanks, Bob K.

Neal@F14 01-05-2011 01:10 PM

I considered the same things you did (very nice drawings, BTW!) but was limited by what space I had to work with and what parts and materials I had on hand. I would've much rather had a more straight shot with the plunger, but unfortunately the cowl on the -8 has only about 3/4" of clearance between the servo mounting plate and the fiberglass of the cowl in that area. The RAC servo specs claim to withstand a static holding force capability of about 40 lbs, and a moving thrust capacity of 20 lbs. The specs don't talk about the sheer strength of the plunger, but it seems to be made quite strong, and doesn't flex even when fully extended and I pressed on it pretty hard. I think it will be strong enough, especially considering how much the airflow slows down as it passes thru the SW oil cooler fins. If the plunger breaks, at least the door will be able to flop mostly open in that failure mode. We just wanted to whip up something quick that would help us out with the cold oil temps of winter flying. If I had more time to work on a better design, I'd probably made a fiberglass flange for the rear of the cooler that has a fitting for 4" SCAT tube, and put one of these round butterfly type air controllers inline: http://www.nonstopaviation.com/rv10-...r-p-14566.html

EDIT: After looking at my own pics a little more, I might just make a nylon wedge spacer to put between the servo and the plate. That would help get the thrust more inline with the plunger, and would be an easy, cheap and simple improvement.

L.Adamson 01-05-2011 06:16 PM

Due to others experience, it seems that a restriction on the front side of the cooler has been working much better than the back. Seems that the oil still get's somewhat cooled anyway, when the door is on the back. Anyway, that seems to be the experience of others. If yours is cooling satisifactory........then good.

L.Adamson --- RV6A

Scott Hersha 01-08-2011 07:12 AM

Another oil cooler option to help warm the oil is one that Larry Vetterman uses. He installed a ball shut-off valve in the oil line leading to the oil cooler, control by a vernier cable in the cockpit. In the 'closed' position it's not fully closed, but any intermediate position restricts oil flow through the cooler in varying amounts, or full open makes it like it's not there. He can control his oil temp to within a couple degrees. Larry says for his engine, the perfect oil temp is 195-197, and at this temp his engine is the smoothest. He's able to maintain this temp summer or winter with his setup.

On my RV-8, I have installed the Van's oil cooler shutter, mounted between the oil cooler and the baffle. I had to modify it because when I bolted it in the first time, tightening the mounting bolts squeezed the shutter so tight you couldn't move the lever. I cut notches in the moving shutter parts and installed a spacer in the center, top and bottom, and it works now, but still a little stiff. To make matters worse, I had to cut the length of the lever down to clear my cowl and now the force required to open/close it is pretty high. Plus the total movement length from open to closed is only about 1/2". I couldn't put it in upside down because of interference with other parts. I'm going to test fly it today, but I'm not real hopeful it will be very good. I had a blocking plate in front at first and it worked, but only worked well at a given OAT.

Sorry abut hijacking your thread. Accurate oil temperature control is frustrating.......

L.Adamson 01-08-2011 07:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott Hersha (Post 501812)
On my RV-8, I have installed the Van's oil cooler shutter, mounted between the oil cooler and the baffle. I had to modify it because when I bolted it in the first time, tightening the mounting bolts squeezed the shutter so tight you couldn't move the lever. I cut notches in the moving shutter parts and installed a spacer in the center, top and bottom, and it works now, but still a little stiff. To make matters worse, I had to cut the length of the lever down to clear my cowl and now the force required to open/close it is pretty high. Plus the total movement length from open to closed is only about 1/2". I couldn't put it in upside down because of interference with other parts. I'm going to test fly it today, but I'm not real hopeful it will be very good. I had a blocking plate in front at first and it worked, but only worked well at a given OAT.

The oil shutter from Van's ....needs washers for spacing. Otherwise, the shutter is pressed against the fins of the cooler. Once you've got that spacing, the shutter door operates very freely. On my initial installation, I ran into the same problem. BTW -- we're having good success around here, with the shutter setup.

L.Adamson --- RV6A

Sheldon 01-08-2011 08:23 AM

This is how I did it with Van's firewall kit... Just made a butterfly valve contolling the amount of air to the cooler controlled via push/pull cable...Works well.... Sheldon

http://picasaweb.google.com/lh/photo...eat=directlink


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:37 AM.