| Kevin Horton |
09-24-2010 04:41 PM |
Quote:
Originally Posted by Kevin Horton
(Post 469866)
Von Alexander used a Setrab oil cooler on his RV-8. He died following an in-flight fire that was triggered when his oil cooler burst, if I recall correctly. I'd use an aviation oil cooler for an aviation engine in an aircraft.
|
I made the original post when I was on the road, and didn't have access to my archive of RV postings. I searched that archive, and can't find the message that described the teardown and failure analysis of Von Alexander's accident. So that might be bad data.
But, I did find messages describing two different castrophic Setrab oil cooler failures on RVs with Lycomings. One failed on an RV-4 three miles from an airport, and he landed with three quarts of oil remaining. And Laird Owens had a big hole blow in the Setrab oil cooler on his RV-6, spraying oil all over the place, and dropping his oil pressure to 5 psi. He managed to get on the ground OK too.
Aircraft oil coolers are subjected to much higher pressures than oil coolers on many automobiles. One of the threads about a Setrab failure had the following statement:
Quote:
Brain Costello, Textron Lycoming service rep, told me at the time (and
confirmed again today) that the oil cooler circuit sees *unregulated* oil
pressure which typically exceeds 250 psi (and can be over 350 psi in a
poorly executed cold weather start). IMHO, this is not the place for 'high
performance' automotive oil coolers, some of which advertise being tested
with air to 175 psi (or less).
|
I've got no dog in this hunt, as I don't sell oil coolers. But I would think long and hard before I used an automotive oil cooler on a Lycoming. I know there are folks who have used these coolers for many hours with no problem, but there have been at least two failures on RVs, with probably much less than 100 installations. I don't like those odds.
|