I have a Catto on the front of my -8. I have an IO-360-A3B6D, and am very happy with the combination. On a cold day at gross weight, I see around 1300 fpm, solo is about 2000 fpm (but I am a VERY heavy lad).
Our airfield is about 400' AGL, and on a 90F degree day, I see about 900 fpm at gross and 1400 fpm solo. Now, these are what I have noticed, rather than measured.
As far as speed is concerned, I once got 190kts in level flight at 3000'. Normal cruise at 2300 RPM at 5000' is about 160 kts. I'm cheap, so most of my local flying is done at 2200-2300 RPM, keeping the burn rate below 8 gal/hr.
My friend has an -8 with an O-360-A1A and a Sensenich FP prop. At solo weights, my airplane is 100 lbs heavier than his (yes, that is all ME, not the airplane). He has me in the climb by a little bit (we do formation take offs and he is about 2 kts faster once wheels are up and we are established in the climb). However, as soon as we level, I'm all over him in speed. He typically needs 125-150 RPM more to maintain the same speed as me.
Not scientific, I know, but there you go. I'm happy with my prop. It looks really cool, is very smooth, light, and very inexpensive. I satisfied with the performance, or at least until I win a lottery, then we'll see ;-).
Cheers