Day Trip to NY City

I will be in NY visiting my sister just outside of Binghamton NY, about 30-40 RV min from NY City. Kids really want to see the Statue of Liberty and some of the other sites.

What is the best airport to fly into, and once there what is the best way to get into the city. Also, if you have 12 hrs in NYC, with 2 children(10 & 12) what other items are must-see.

Thanks for any advice.

New York

Fly to the Hudson River somewhere north of the Bravo airspace and you can fly all the way down the Hudson corridor at low altitude. For a day trip you need a close in airport, either Teterboro with lots of corporate jet traffic and very expensive, or Linden, less expensive and much less traffic. Linden appears intimidating at first but if you approach from the south and get below 800' where appropriate it is relatively easy. There is a train from near Linden to Manhattan. On your Hudson tour you can circle the Statue of Liberty. Be sure to get a New York Terminal Chart, detailed information on the corridor is on the back. Fuel prices are some of the highest in the US, but there is some less expensive fuel in the area.

Thanks,
Is that a subway train, or a Amtrack type train from Lindon?
(Do I need to purchase tickets in advance)
I have not been to NY since I was about 10 yr old.

train

Go to njtransit.com, it will give you schedules and prices. Trains run frequently, about a 40 minute trip to Penn Station. You can also take a cab to Newark Airport and take a bus to Manhattan, but this is more time consuming.

NYC

Republic Airport (KFRG) is in Farmingdale, NY on Long Island and has train service on the Long Island Railroad. If you park at an FBO they will take you and pick you up from the train station.
The FBO's are listed here: http://www.republicairport.net/fixed-based-operators.htm

As for things to do in Manhattan in the summer with the kids I would take walk to Times Square and have lunch at the Hard Rock Cafe. http://www.republicairport.net/fixed-based-operators.htm

Also, you can visit the Madame Tussauds Wax Museum which is right there in Times Square http://www.madametussauds.com/newyork/

If time allows I would walk a few blocks over to Fifth Avenue and walk north taking in the sites of the stores until you get to 58 Street. There you have FAO Shwarz, the Largest and Oldest Toy Store. It is amazing! http://www.fao.com/shop/index.jsp?categoryId=3810526

Also, you are now across the street from the entrance to Central Park. Walk west one block and you will see horse drawn carriages and drivers dressed up in costume with cool hats. Take the family for a ride around Central Park in a horse drawn carriage! http://www.centralpark.com/guide/activities/horse-drawn-carriages.html

Other ideas are a Circle Line boat ride around Manhattan, a trip to the top of the Empire State Building, The Museum of Natural History, The 9/11 Memorial, if it's a Wednesday or Saturday go to a Broadway Show Afternoon Matinee. Endless possibilities! Just bring a credit card...

Linden

Linden Airport website is lindenairportnj.com
You will find a google map that will show the railroad. Linden airport is on route 1. NE on route 1 to South Wood Ave, then NW about 8 short blocks to the railroad. No need to go to Long Island. You have to go around LaGuardia and JFK airspace to get to Republic. Republic is likely quite a bit busier than Linden.
The website shows Linden airport with the Manhattan skyline in the background.

VLAD is the expert. Ask for his opinion.

Tonard Bales said:

Republic Airport (KFRG) is in Farmingdale, NY on Long Island and has train service on the Long Island Railroad. If you park at an FBO they will take you and pick you up from the train station.
The FBO's are listed here: http://www.republicairport.net/fixed-based-operators.htm

As for things to do in Manhattan in the summer with the kids I would take walk to Times Square and have lunch at the Hard Rock Cafe. http://www.republicairport.net/fixed-based-operators.htm

Also, you can visit the Madame Tussauds Wax Museum which is right there in Times Square http://www.madametussauds.com/newyork/

If time allows I would walk a few blocks over to Fifth Avenue and walk north taking in the sites of the stores until you get to 58 Street. There you have FAO Shwarz, the Largest and Oldest Toy Store. It is amazing! http://www.fao.com/shop/index.jsp?categoryId=3810526

Also, you are now across the street from the entrance to Central Park. Walk west one block and you will see horse drawn carriages and drivers dressed up in costume with cool hats. Take the family for a ride around Central Park in a horse drawn carriage! http://www.centralpark.com/guide/activities/horse-drawn-carriages.html

Other ideas are a Circle Line boat ride around Manhattan, a trip to the top of the Empire State Building, The Museum of Natural History, The 9/11 Memorial, if it's a Wednesday or Saturday go to a Broadway Show Afternoon Matinee. Endless possibilities! Just bring a credit card...

Click to expand...

Couldn't say it better Anthony. My vote goes to KFRG FBOs this time

There is already a little back and forth from the locals (of which I'm one, from NJ actually) as to which airport to fly in to, and I'd suggest you should take that as a hint that you don't have really convenient options here in terms of GA airports to fly to in order to easily access NYC on a one day trip for sight-seeing in Manhattan -- not to say it can't be done if you're really ambitious and ready for a long day.

So I'd suggest you think carefully about your planning, logistics for getting around, and the time it will take you to do it all. Maybe your best bet, considering you're starting out with a 40 minute flight from Binghamton, is to just fly in and do the awesome Hudson River Corridor flight for spectacular sight-seeing (Statue of Liberty, Ground Zero, New Liberty Tower, Manhattan skyline, George Washington Bridge, Verrazzano Bridge, etc.) and call it a day and return to Binghamton. If you do, make sure you understand the airspace, procedures and self-announcements you are to make in the corridor. See here: http://www.faasafety.gov/files/gslac/courses/content/79/776/kneeboard.pdf
If you want an airport with a restaurant to stop at on the way back, you could go to Blairstown (1N7) in Northern, NJ, which is a nice country airport (gliders, etc) right on your route with a decent cafe/restaurant (http://www.blairstownairport.com/default.htm).

I haven't journeyed from either Linden or Republic Airports into Manhattan, but you can see that they are really not that close. Google maps shows Republic at about 40 miles drive by car to downtown Manhattan, while it shows Linden to be about 26 miles. It's already been said that the train ride from Linden to Penn Station in NYC is about 40 minutes, and the trip from Farmingdale is closer to an hour. Assuming you don't rent a car, that leaves you to get from the airport to the closest train station by cab or otherwise, wait for the next train to arrive, then take it to NYC and start traveling around to your final destination within the city from there. That's going to take you some time, and obviously you're going to have to do it in reverse when you're finished, then get back in your plane for your 40 minute ride back to Binghamton.

If you think you can overcome the obstacles, I'd vote Linden, since it's (a) closer on your way from Binghamton, and (b) closer to NYC than Republic, and (c) only about 1.5 miles to the NJ Transit train station (but you will need a cab for that). However, to get in to Linden, you will be flying at low level under Class B over some densely populated areas with basically no landing areas, so I agree with Vlad it's intimidating. Here's the NJ Transit train schedule for Linden to NYC: http://www.njtransit.com/pdf/rail/R0070.pdf

However, my vote, if you decide to go for this marathon, would be to not take the train from Linden all the way to Penn Station at 34th St. in central Manhattan, but rather to get off at Penn Station in Newark (that's right, Newark and Manhattan each have stations confusingly named Penn Station, but one is in Newark and the other in NYC) and transfer onto the "PATH" train to the World Trade Center station in lower Manhattan, where you will get off right at the World Trade Center and can check out the 9/11 memorial, etc. You can see the PATH schedule on the NJ Transit schedule linked above. That might be a trip into Manhattan you could accomplish in one day coming from Binghamton with an early start.

My other vote, if you had the time, for sight-seeing in NYC with kids would be to go to Battery Park, at the lower tip of Manhattan, with a beautiful view of NY harbor and the Statute of Liberty, with a little museum of the old fort, and then take the ferry ride tour to the Statue of Liberty and Ellis Island. What a great trip that is, for you and the kids. Here's the info here: http://www.statuecruises.com/ The tour tickets are surprisingly cheap, compared to everything else in NYC, where fleecing tourists is an art. To get there, you would also take the PATH to the World Trade Center station, and you could then actually walk to Battery Park, going right past the NY Stock Exchange. It would take an early start and serious ambition, though, to pull that whole trip off in a day coming from and returning to Binghamton, so I'm not sure I'd advise it. You as the pilot would surely be pooped at the end of such a day. You'd never forget it though.

Good luck!

Hudson Route

Its well worth it. we flew from KHPN then south to NY and through the corridor. KHPN was nice and it was reasonable.

NY

There is no question that Republic is a nicer airport than Linden. However the statements about the intimidation factor are very misleading. From the midpoint of the eastern side of Staten Island to Linden Airport is only about 10NM. From the vicinity of the Verrazano Bridge to Republic is about 35 nm. Add in the extra 40 minutes round trip on the train from Republic plus the extra flight time and you have wasted one hour plus.
Look at a google map of Staten Island. About midway on the east side of the island is Miller Field, an abandoned airport. It is a very visible landmark. From just south of Miller field, straight to the west, there are NO published obstructions of any significance. About half of this route is unpopulated areas, few if any are suitable for emergency landings. Remain just outside the Newark 6.5NM ring, below 1500', until directly south of Linden Airport, then down to below 800' before crossing the Newark 6.5 arc.
If Newark is using runway4(parallels), landing traffic will be about 1500' abeam of Linden Airport.If Newark is using runway 22, the traffic over Linden will be higher. This gives a lot of separation for Linden traffic pattern. The goal is to keep your pattern close in to Linden, especially landing to the west. Study the airport diagram and traffic pattern as well as the routing from Staten Island. It is really much easier than it looks.